Comments on: Compare the Final 3

By: skittles

skittles — Mon, 26 Jan 2009 00:52:19 +0000

I like all of the final 3 girls, but analeigh was overrated by her fans. I like her though.

By: Mike

Mike — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 00:59:34 +0000

Promo: Analeigh
Pre show: Mckey
Voting: Mckey
Rope Ladder: Mckey
Makeovers: Mckey
Swimsuit: Samantha
Fierce Eyes: Analeigh
Natural Disasters: Samantha
Award Show Snafus: Analeigh
CG Comemrcial: Analeigh
17th Century Women: Mckey
Simplistic: Samantha
Dramatic: Mckey
Windmill: Mckey

Overall:
Who do you want to win: Mckey
Who is going to win: Mckey//Analeigh

By: Kyle

Kyle — Wed, 19 Nov 2008 15:48:54 +0000

You are amazing for doing this!!! Plus you organized everything very well! I thought I was the only one interested in comparing them!

Promo: Analeigh
Pre show: Analeigh
Voting: McKey
Rope Ladder: Samantha
Makeovers: McKey
Swimsuit: McKey
Fierce Eyes: McKey (but also liked Analeigh’s)
Natural Disasters: Samantha
Award Show Snafus: Analeigh
CG Comemrcial: Analeigh
17th Century Women: McKey
Simplistic: McKey
Dramatic: Analeigh
Windmill: Analeigh (but also loved Mckey’s)
Final Two: Analeigh and McKey
Winner: McKey (but will be happy if Analeigh wins!)

By: final 2

final 2 — Wed, 19 Nov 2008 06:58:01 +0000

best portfolio-Samantha
most comemrcial-Analeigh
most hf-Mckey
who do i want 2 win-Samantha
who will win-Mckey

By: final 2

final 2 — Wed, 19 Nov 2008 06:54:16 +0000

Promo: mckey
Pre show: Analeighs ass is showing
Voting: mckey
Rope Ladder: McKey
Makeovers: Samantha
Swimsuit: Samantha
Fierce Eyes: Samantha
Natural Disasters: Samantha
Award Show Snafus: Analeigh
CG Comemrcial: Analeigh
17th Century Women: Samantha
Simplistic: Samantha
Dramatic: Analeigh was not as good as sams Simplistic
Windmill: mckey
final 2 Samantha-Mckey

By: Rebecca

Rebecca — Tue, 18 Nov 2008 12:22:19 +0000

Promo: Analeigh
Pre show: Analeigh
Voting: Samantha
Rope Ladder: McKey
Makeovers: Samantha
Swimsuit: Samantha
Fierce Eyes: Samantha
Natural Disasters: Samantha
Award Show Snafus: Analeigh
CG Comemrcial: Analeigh
17th Century Women: Samantha
Simplistic: Samantha
Dramatic: Analeigh
Windmill: analeigh

Overall: Analeigh
Who do you want to win: Samantha
Who is going to win: Analeigh.

By: AVee

AVee — Tue, 18 Nov 2008 10:57:40 +0000

Promo: Analeigh
Pre show: Analeigh
Voting: McKey
Rope Ladder: McKey
Makeovers: McKey
Swimsuit: McKey
Fierce Eyes: Analeigh
Natural Disasters: McKey(almost a tie, though. And I can’t pick the worst)
Award Show Snafus: Analeigh
CG Comemrcial: Analeigh
17th Century Women: McKey
Simplistic: McKey
Dramatic: McKey
Windmill: Analeigh

Overall: McKey
Who do you want to win: McKey
Who is going to win: McKey

At first I was rooting all the way for Analeigh, but some weeks later, I changed my mind. McKey’s gonna take home the title, I’m sure of it.

By: honestlyantm

honestlyantm — Tue, 18 Nov 2008 07:38:21 +0000

Kim’s no longer with Elite, I’m pretty sure she was dropped.

By: R0ck1n C0utur3

R0ck1n C0utur3 — Tue, 18 Nov 2008 06:48:27 +0000

***************************

*Promo – Mckey
(she came out as this simple “Red head” girl from Illnois…..then when Tyra asked Mckey to put her hair up…you see a GORGEOUS,edgy,spunky, hi-fashion model)

*Pre show:

*Voting: Mckey
(she has raw talent!…even though she didn’t know how to pose as much as some of the other girls…her pic came out one of the strongest faces.)

*Rope Ladder: Analiegh
(she had elegant poses…the clothing/garment moved beautifully…her pose was beautiful.)

*Makeovers: Mckey
(one of the fiercest transformation I’ve ever seen in ANTM history!!….I’d kill for her look and face!)

*Swimsuit: Mckey
(her face was absolutely GORGEOUS!…eyes were gleaming….strong face…..strong posture……just perfection!)

*Fierce Eyes: Mckey

*Natural Disasters: Mckey
(It was like watching a SUPER model on set!…her poses were absolutely breath taking….so many variations…Hi-FASHION…editorial with edge..so many amazing poses =)…Samantha’s chosen photo was amazing too.

*Award Show Snafus: MCKEY
(I love her gorgeous & classic face…very Armani!)

*CG Comemrcial: Analiegh
(I think she’s a little more commercial than Hi-fashion/editorial)

*17th Century Women: MCKEY.
(she killed it!! her legs were aammaazing….she showed off the garments well and the shoes….her posture was very editorial)

*Simplistic: Mckey
(face and posture was natural and beautiful!)

*Dramatic: Mckey
(I love her spunk!…..I bet you she will become an International model…many designers would want her….seriously!!)

*Windmill: Mckey
(yet another stong photo….she gets better and develops even better every week!)

Overall: Mckey
Who do you want to win: MCKEY!!!
Who is going to win: MCKEY!!!! MCKEY!!

>>>>>>MCKEY has the best runway walk…she adds her own flavor to it…She has one of the most gorgeous faces I’ve seen in a long while in the modeling world….her look is to die for…..I’m gona say this again…….>>>She’s spunky…editorial…hi-fasion…edgy…Unique Beauty =)

______________________________

(to tell you the truth it doesn’t matter whether Mckey doesn’t win or not…because I know for sure that she will be signed by a modeling agency…..(I mean come on….she booked ALL of her Go-sees!!!)…that girl is fierce!……

**note—>> some of the ANTM girls who didn’t win the show….are actually doing very well…some are for ELITE…some are doing INTERNATIONAL….Mollie Sue…Elyse…..Anya’s doing good…..Kim Stolz is on MTV and she’s also in ELITE…Katarzyna (cycle 10) is doing international work too…mostly in NY ***

By: Hannah

Hannah — Tue, 18 Nov 2008 00:06:43 +0000

Promo: McKey. Blank slate face, showing off her body simply.
Pre show: McKey. Another simple, flattering shot.
Voting: Analeigh. Only one to convey a story.
Rope Ladder: Analeigh. Shows off the dress the best.
Makeovers: Samantha. Switched me over from thinking she was boring-looking (only to be replaced by ridiculous-looking after she started messing with her hair, but still).
Swimsuit: Samantha. Quite intimate.
Fierce Eyes: Analeigh, but only for that leg. Eyes-wise, none of the above.
Natural Disasters: McKey. She looks languid like one might expect in a heat wave. Samantha looks stoned.
Award Show Snafus: Analeigh and McKey… it’s a tie, I can’t choose one. They’re both fantastic. They’ve both got the faces picture-perfect. Samantha just looks like she’s screwing up her face to throw a tantrum.
CG Commercial: Uh, Analeigh. McKey looks uncomfortable and Samantha looks crazy. But I’m surprised anyone can pull off lines like that without seeming uncomfortable or crazy!
17th Century Women: I hate all of these, actually, but I’ll say McKey for the legs alone.
Simplistic: Analeigh. She doesn’t need some kind of category (boyish or sideways or whatever) to look good.
Dramatic: Analeigh. She looks like she’s being blown away from that wall by a very strong wind.
Windmill: McKey. It’s the first time I really felt the appeal of her face. Analeigh might have been a strong challenger, but her legs are scary. They look like sausages here.

Overall: Tallying them up, I guess it’s Analeigh.

Who do you want to win: Not Samantha! Looking back on these, more than ever, I see that she’s not remotely on the same pictorial level as the other two. I would be okay with either Analeigh or McKey winning.

Who is going to win: I feel like Analeigh’s been given a compassionate edit, a workable makeover, and hasn’t been outright set up for failure like some girls have (Sheena, Isis)… I feel like Analeigh’s been able to showcase her best potential during this show.
McKey, however, while fawned over in panel, is rarely shown in the house or given confessional time to endear us to her, AND she received, in my opinion, pretty much the Worst. Hair. Ever. Without that hair as a handicap, I feel like she’s capable of much, much more than we’ve seen (a successful post-show career perfect for Tyra to parade in front of us in MLAACG episodes)!
So really I don’t know. Depends on whether the judges decide to finally pick a high-fashion model or base their decision on who can shill CG products.